Founded in 1990 by Alan Caruba, a business and science writer, the Center is a clearinghouse for information about "scare campaigns" designed to influence public opinion and policies. Read Caruba's daily commentaries at "Warning Signs" (see favorite sites)
Email email@example.com or firstname.lastname@example.org.
Wednesday, March 11, 2015
The EPA Thinks You're Stupid
The folks at the Environmental
Protection Agency, starting with a long line of its administrators that now
includes Gina McCarthy, think you and the Congress of the United States are
stupid. They have been telling lies for so long they can’t imagine that their
chokehold on the American economy will ever end.
It is, however, coming to an end and
the reason is a Republican-controlled Congress responding to the countless
businesses and individuals being ravaged by a ruthless bureaucracy driven by an
environmental agenda determined to deprive America of the energy sources vital
to our lives and the nation’s existence.
This was on display in early March
when Gina McCarthy testified to the Senate Environmental and Public Works
Committee, asking for a nearly $500 million increase in its 2016 budget. The
total discretionary budget request would have topped out at $8.6 billion and
would reward states nearly $4 billion to go along with the EPA’s Clean Power
The problem is that the Clean Power
Plan is really about no power or far more costly power in those states where the
EPA has been shutting down coal-fired plants that not long ago provided fifty
percent of all the electricity in the nation.
“More than 72 gigawatts (GW) of
electrical generating capacity have already, or are now set to retire because of
the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) regulations. The regulations causing
these closures include the Mercury and Air Toxics Standards (colloquially called
MATS, or Utility MACT), proposed Cross State Air Pollution Rule (CSAPR), and the
proposed regulation of carbon dioxide emissions from existing power
To put 72 GW in perspective,
that is enough electrical generation capacity to reliably power 44.7 million
homes—or every home in every state west of the Mississippi River, excluding
Texas. In other words, EPA is shutting down enough generating capacity to power
every home in Washington, Oregon, California, Idaho, Nevada, Arizona, Utah,
Montana, Wyoming, Colorado, New Mexico, North and South Dakota, Nebraska,
Kansas, Oklahoma, Minnesota, Iowa, Missouri, Arkansas, and
Plants closed or soon to
Over 94 percent these retirements will
come from generating units at coal-fired power plants, shuttering over one-fifth
of the U.S.’s coal-fired generating capacity. While some of the effected units
will be converted to use new fuels, American families and businesses will pay
the price with higher utility bills and less reliability for their
What nation would knowingly reduce its
capacity to produce the electricity that everyone depends upon?
Answer: The United States of America.
Why? Because the EPA has been telling
us that coal-fired plants produce carbon dioxide (CO2) and it is causing ours
and the world’s temperature to increase to a point that threatens our lives.
They have been claiming
that everything from blizzards to droughts, hurricanes to forest fires, are the
result of the CO2 that coal-fired plants produce.
That is a huge, stupendous lie.
In the Senate Committee meeting,
McCarthy said, “Climate change is real. It is happening. It is a threat. Humans
are causing the majority of that threat...the impacts are being felt. Climate
change is not a religion. It is not a belief system. It’s a scientific fact. And
our challenge is to move forward with the actions we need to protect future
Climate change is real. It’s been real for 4.5 billion years and
it has absolutely nothing to do with anything that humans do, least of all
heating, cooling and lighting their homes, running their businesses, and
everything else that requires electricity.
McCarthy said that the EPA’s overall
goal was to save the planet from rising sea levels, massive storms, and other
climate events that impact our lives. No, that’s not why the EPA was
created in 1970. Its job was to clean the water and the air. It has done a
relatively good job, but its mandate had nothing to do with the climate, nor
does the provision of energy have any impact on the climate.
The reverse is true. The climate has a
lot of impact on us.
Regarding the “science” McCarthy
referred to, according to a 2013 report by the Intergovernmental Panel on
Climate Change, there were record low tornadoes, record low hurricanes, record
gain in Arctic and Antarctic ice, no change in the rate of sea levels,
and there had been NO WARMING at that point for 17—now
When Sen. Jeff Sessions asked McCarthy
a number of questions about droughts and hurricanes, she either dodged providing
a specific answer or claimed, as with hurricanes, that “I cannot answer that
question. It’s a very complicated issue.”
Asked about the computer models on
which the EPA makes its regulatory decisions, McCarthy replied, “I do not know
what the models actually are predicting that you are referring to.” Sen.
Sessions said that it was incredible that the Administrator of the EPA “doesn’t
know whether their predictions have been right or
As for any “science” the EPA may be
using, much of it is SECRET.
Sterling Burnett, the managing editor of the Heartland Institute’s Environment &
Climate News, reported on The Secret Science Reform Act (HR 4012)
introduced by the House Science Committee late last year. The bill would
“prohibit the Environmental Protection Agency from proposing, finalizing, or
disseminating regulations or assessments based on science that is not
transparent or reproducible.”
The House passed the Act on November
20, 2014 and it has been received in the Senate, read twice, and referred to the
Committee on Environment and Public Works. If it passes the Senate, that will be
a giant leap forward in gaining oversight and control of the
Until then, the EPA’s administrator
and staff will continue to work their mischief in the belief that both Congress
and the rest of us are stupid. We’re not.